Balancing discretion and certainty
How should we balance the need for discretion in applying water abstraction restrictions against the need to provide clear expectations for businesses upfront?
Why the contribution is important
Some discretion is important because the individual circumstances at a catchment level can be very different. Having a degree of discretion allows for flexibility at the catchment level. In the recent past the way in which the Environment Agency has used its discretion in applying section 57 restrictions on irrigators has been praised (see the supporting information for more information). However many businesses and individuals may also want a level of certainty on when restrictions will apply in order to help them plan.
by abstractionreform on September 05, 2014 at 10:58AM
Posted by phammett September 05, 2014 at 15:39
Report this Comment (Requires Log In)
Posted by anglianwater September 11, 2014 at 16:35
While an absolutely secure permanent right to a specific volume of water is unachievable, but it is critical that the reform proposals ensure water property rights are as secure as possible. The less secure are the property rights over water, the more likely it will be that investment in essential infrastructure will not be forthcoming, and that trade of water rights and other forms of commercial exchange which will realize economic value will be discouraged.
In particular, we believe that under a reformed system licences should be designed to avoid the need to alter the rights which are granted by them. Specifically, licence conditions should specify parameters which do not need to be changed in order to vary the amount of water that is allowed to be taken under the licence. On these grounds there would be advantages to the Water Shares option, because the right to a share of available water (in a particular reliability pool) seems less likely to need to be changed than the volume limits which are defined in a Hands-Off-Flow (HOF) licence condition.
Report this Comment (Requires Log In)
Posted by abstractionreform September 24, 2014 at 13:55
Giving the Environment Agency discretion in when to apply restrictions allows them to ensure they are getting the level of environmental protection right as well as targeting the right abstractions. This links to our other discussion thread about getting the right level of environmental protection during a drought: http://defra.dialogue-app.com/[…]/protecting-the-environment
Report this Comment (Requires Log In)
Posted by SouthStaffsWater October 09, 2014 at 13:20
Report this Comment (Requires Log In)
Posted by DCWW October 10, 2014 at 10:43
Report this Comment (Requires Log In)